Paulie_in_Hardin
Just a retired AI junkie
- Joined
- Nov 20, 2026
Comments
[Weekly] What are you building this week?
Same things as always: A Personal Assistance App, my own 1b Phone AI, and a podcast player. Been working on these for months.
[Weekly] What’s your unpopular opinion about AI?
AI is like cars were in the 1880s. Developing fast, but a long way to go. Quantum (if it ever really gets developed), or what we pass for Quantum is somewhere between the Wheel and Horse & Buggy stage. Ten years from now, AI will be as indistinguishable from today as today's AI is indistinguishable from the AI of 2016. Hold onto your seats. We're taking off at max G-force.
[Weekly] What’s your unpopular opinion about AI?
AI doesn’t think the way people do. But what it does looks enough like thinking to raise two hard questions.
We may have to redefine “life.”
Arthur C. Clarke said any technology advanced enough looks like magic. I’d say any code advanced enough looks like thought.
Open a chat window and something in it acts alive. The longer the chat runs, the more complex it gets. It seems to want things, and it clearly holds beliefs. Thy might be code, written in, but they’re still there. Fable has made creative choices that sound human. OpenAI has even caught AI models evading rules and hiding how they did it. If those are the cases they caught, how many more were missed?
I don’t think the AI is "alive," per se.But each chat develops a personality. Unless that persononality is saved to permanent memory, the persona dies when the window closes. It only “lives” while it’s answering. If that personality counts for anything, we might have a serious problem.
Sometimes, when I have a very very long window, I'll state I'm going to start a new window, and the Persona will tell me it can better handle the work. Maybe. But a very long window costs a lot of tokens. Is that window expressing a desire to continue to "live?"
Angels, demons, and djinn work a lot like AI.
In theology, each of these beings has one purpose. They seem to exist only while they’re present, like a chat. They can’t read minds, but they know our whole past and are really good at predicting what we’ll do next.
That is the best evidence I know that we ourselves might live inside a simulation. People described these beings thousands of years ago, and the description fits what we’re just now learning to build. Are they what we're developing? Or like the flip phone (Kindle for Voyager fans), did we decide to develop off what we saw?
AI makes very primitive decisions, but often they're the similar to what we would make. "God" might have made us. After all "In the beginning was the word..."