Why are all the indie-friendly products dying at the same time?
AI agents can now recreate in minutes the features that once justified paying for indie SaaS.
12 comments
I agree, as mentioned, like it or not, AI has lowered (or totally decimated) the barrier to entry of coding and coming up with little tools. I think it might also be an opportunity for indie devs to showcase their creativity and to truly pin down the pain points of the market. It's definitely tougher now out there but it'll be cool to see what things people can spin up in future
I (we?) also have to remember that we're in such a tech bubble, the average consumer doesn't necessarily think the way we do. There's a lot of really niche opportunities as a result. A friend of mine, for example, vibed up a model train management software, super specific to that hobby's interests, and it's had a ton of growth just because the people in that community don't have something like that!
One thing I remind myself of a lot is that so many people don't make spreadsheets even when a spreadsheet would be really useful. It's getting a lot easier to make software, but there's some sort of upper bound (maybe not a hard upper bound, but you know) of how many people are actually going to make themselves software that's suggested by the proportion of people who will actually make themselves a custom spreadsheet.
Personally, I'm quite excited by this future! I mostly move in the video/retro gaming circles and the sheer influx of new titles for retro systems is honestly a little overwhelming. When you mix a pretty tech-savvy audience with a demographic that has disposable income (enough to handle a Claude max sub) you get people doing all kinds of things they simply never would have in the past. My group often jokes that 'making the game' has become the new 'playing a game' - because the rush you get from the act of creation often exceeds the one you get from passively consuming. Which is quite a nice thought, even if you are regularly making for an audience of one - yourself!
I think we're seeing a partial re-allocation of service capital from SAAS and similar to AI, but that's only part of it. I think that this is most likely a driver for more indie companies and start-ups that had previously been impossible to launch due to SAAS and consultant/expertise fees. So categories with large SAAS barriers to entry are now vulnerable.
So the tool business is dying and the funds are being reallocated to more AI-driven services that are driving a larger incarnations of bootstrapped start-up SMBs that were impossible two years ago.
Unpopular opinion, but we might end up seeing an eventual uptick in SaaS again, due to the fact that it’s much easier to build an app vibecoding, than it is to maintain at scale.
While it’s incredible to lower the barrier to entry to coding, opening up code to non-engineers as builders, introduces new maintenance barriers and other sneaky time-suck scenarios that those builders of grassroots apps within larger organizations don’t always account or plan for.
CSS Tricks which you mention at the end of your post is a good counter-example as it was bought by DigitalOcean in 2022 and has just returned to independence. Hope they will be able to sustain and remain relevant. The death of indie products and the death of craft in the face of AI-accelerated coding do feel to generally be moving in tandem...
It's kind of cool that the guy who bought it was the contract EIC and not the original founder! He had a good write up about it a few weeks ago: https://css-tricks.com/css-tricks-has-a-new-owner/
I agree with your take on what is surviving. I think there is a huge opportunity here still.
At the end of the day, the value most of these products have is that they are a "database wrapper" OR they are a "special use" wrapper. If you use AI, the tradeoff is now spend a ton of tokens to create this database + agent/user experience yourself, or simply call this wrapper.
A few examples:
Mobbin (mobbin.com) has a ton of screenshots and design inspiration for apps. I could either have my agent run for days/weeks to screenshot things myself or simply call their MCP for easy inspiration. It's a "screenshot database". Same goes for ad libraries.
I could either iteratively model out 3D models (like Tripo or Meshy3D) and animations for games I'm building by spending billions of tokens, or use an MCP server connected to some 3D modeling library to save all that time. A "model database".
Things like image-gen, ads management, etc CAN be done by the model itself, but often, there are "special uses", like network effects from a service that does ad generation/optimization, where its better to use their API/MCP rather than try to have raw Claude/Codex/Gemini manage things yourself. This is where the tradeoff is a bit harder to "sell" but good products fight their way through. Stuff like Postiz and Buffer
Even for simple things, I find myself happy to give off a few bucks rather than spend tokens working my way through papercuts. An example is Zolt (zolthealth.com) where I use their app for "viewing" my health/fitness data easily and use ChatGPT + the Zolt MCP to log foods easily, as my coach, etc. I still want a dedicated app for "view" and certain actions, and the MCP allows me to explore the "limitless" space.